We all know about males identifying as female and then competing against females in athletic events. Lia Thomas is the most well-known example; Lia switched from the men’s swim team to the women’s at the University of Pennsylvania. Lia ranked 65th in the nation in the 500 freestyle while swimming as a male, but was an NCAA champion in that event when swimming as a female, even beating the reigning Olympic women’s silver medalist. There is also a growing number of biologically male high school athletes who are going out for girls’ teams, and although many are not winning events or setting records, they still displace biological females on those teams and could keep biological high school girls from getting college scholarships.

But you don’t have to be transgender to be on a team of the opposite sex. Many states allow girls to try out for boys’ teams, especially if there is not a sanctioned girls’ team for their given sport. Iowa is one such state, which leads us to the subject of this story.

Reanah Utterback loves wrestling. As a freshman at Sigourney High School in Iowa, she wrestled on the 2021-22 Sigourney-Keota boys’ team since the Iowa Girls High School Athletic Union (IGHSAU) didn’t recognize wrestling as a sanctioned varsity sport. She had a 38-5 record in the 106-pound weight class, pinning 14 of her male opponents, and qualifying for the boys Class 1A (small schools) state tournament. She is one of only six girls to qualify for the boys’ state tournament in wrestling since girls were allowed to compete against boys.

Her path to the state tournament included a second-place finish in her sectional tournament, losing 4-0 to Dalton Ervin of Moravia in the final. This allowed her to advance to the district tournament, which she won by avenging her loss to Dalton with a 4-2 overtime victory in the district final. Sadly, she lost twice in the state tournament, getting pinned in her last match, which was the only time she was pinned the entire season.

Even though girls wrestling was not a sanctioned sport, the Iowa Wrestling Coaches and Officials Association (IWCOA) sponsored a girls’ wrestling tournament for the 2021-22 season. Reanah also competed there, winning the 110-pound weight class with five straight victories, all by pin, with four pins occurring in the first period and three within the first minute.

Reanah wins the 110-pound class at the 2022 IWCOA girls’ tournament.

 

In March 2022, Reanah won the 16U 112-pound class at the USA Wrestling Girls Folkstyle Nationals, winning all four matches, three by pin. In May 2022, Reanah placed 7th at the USMC Women’s National U15 Wrestling Tournament in the 50-kg weight class. In October 2022, she won the 106-pound weight class at the Brian Keck Preseason Nationals Wrestling Tournament for high school girls, winning all four matches, three by pin. She is also a member of the AAU and USA Wrestling national girls’ teams.

For the 2022-23 season, the IGHSAU officially sanctioned wrestling as a girls’ sport. But because Sigourney-Keota did not have a girls’ team, Reanah (now a sophomore) was allowed to again join the Sigourney-Keota boys’ team. Her goal: become only the second girl to win a medal – placing 8th or higher — at the boys’ state wrestling tournament. So far the only girl to medal in the boys’ tournament is Megan Black of Cedar Falls, placing 8th in 2012, also in the 106-pound weight class.

Reanah won by forfeit a number of times both this season and last, and I asked Cody Goodwin, who covers wrestling for the Des Moines Register, if that was because boys were forfeiting so they wouldn’t have to wrestle a girl. He didn’t think that was the case, and it was more likely that small schools have a hard time filling out all 14 weight classes every meet. On the other hand, reportedly Megan Black won a match by forfeit in the 2012 state tournament because the boy did not want to wrestle against her.

In the 2022-23 regular season Reanah compiled a 35-8 record with 19 pins, and was not pinned herself. Reanah qualified for the 2023 boys’ state tournament again, becoming only the third girl to do so twice. Reanah was seeded 8th, thereby receiving a bye in the first round. She won her next match 6-4 over the #9 seed to reach the quarterfinals. She then lost to the #1 seed (and eventual champion) by a 10-0 score, which put her in the consolation bracket. There Reanah beat the #12 seed 7-2, but in the next round lost a close 1-0 match to the #4 seed. Finally, she lost 4-0 to the #2 seed in the 7th-place match. Thus Reanah finished in 8th place, equaling Megan Black’s result in 2012. Since Reanah is only a sophomore, she will have two more chances to qualify for the boys’ tournament after this season, and perhaps improve on her 8th-place finish.

Reanah’s own words, as shown on her trackwrestling.com web page, provide the best description of her mindset:

Wrestling is my life. With dedication and determination the desire for greatness is achievable.